Rubric

Keep in mind that 53 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Midterm Rubric (2)
Midterm Rubric (2)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Thesis Paraphrase
Student has constructed a thesis that encompasses the author’s central idea and includes the title/author, is in their own words, and reflects accurately the scope of the article.
threshold: pts
5 to >2.5 pts Yes Spot on
2.5 to >0.0 pts Mostly Your thesis paraphrase may be too specific or too general but overall gets the right idea.
0 pts Missing / Not yet Thesis Paraphrase may not be attempted or may incorrectly recap the article.
pts
5 pts
--
Summary
Summary fits the genre expectations - no opinion, concise, paraphrased, and accurately representing the author's ideas. It doesn't leave out crucial information, or conversely, include too much minute detail. Summary accurately reflects the article, identifying all or most of the major supporting details, and most of the minor supporting details. Summary is written in own words.
threshold: pts
30 to >25.0 pts Yes Your summary accurately captures the article in a succinct way.
25 to >18.0 pts Mostly You're close. Your summary is very very near perfect but may include too many details, or not enough. It may include too many quotes or language may be off. You might have accidentally included your own opinion here.
18 to >0 pts Not Yet Summary is not attempted or missing a lot of key info.
pts
30 pts
--
Rhetorical Analysis
Student has masterfully anlayzed the effectiveness of how the author has written the argument. The writer has avoided just responding in a personal agree/disagree way and instead has identify ~4+ areas to evaluate, which may or may not include evidence, tone, audience awareness, appeals, credibility. Writer uses quotes to support and develop their point.
threshold: pts
50 to >40.0 pts Yes Stellar work!
40 to >25.0 pts Mostly You're close. You have found a few ways in but may not developed your ideas enough. Say more next time. You may have found a quote but didn't integrate it correctly.
25 to >0 pts Not yet Let's keep working on Analysis. You may have too much summary here - no opinions - or they may not be well explained.
pts
50 pts
--
Polish and Requirements
Midterm is polished (spell checked and clearly formatted). follows the length requirements and format requirements, and sentences are relatively error free.
threshold: pts
10 to >7.0 pts Yes 'Nary an error in sight! I can tell you proofread. You also met all the requirements.
7 to >5.0 pts Mostly Take time to read it over a bit more next time. Meet with me in the Writing Center to review your sentences. Double check the requirements.
5 to >0 pts Not yet
pts
10 pts
--
Revision & Voice
Writer utilizes feedback from rough draft and engages with the process of revising reading and writing. Writer develops voice and authentic and original insights in their Rhetorical Analysis.
threshold: pts
5 to >4.0 pts Yes
4 to >2.0 pts Mostly Let's work together on revision and voice next time.
2 to >0 pts Not yet You may have missed all revision feedback.
pts
5 pts
--